Vacation Time! Suggestions?

My family and I will be taking a much needed vacation this summer, and I need your suggestions!

Normally, we go to Rhode Island - as I already have property there.

However, this year my wife is begging to go somewhere more tropical.

Here is what we're looking for:
  • Less than 12 hours by plane from the US
  • Crystal Clear water that you can see through
  • Option to rent a house on the beach
Here are what we are researching right now:
  1. Tahiti
  2. Bora Bora...
Vacation Time! Suggestions?

Poster :
Matthew Sayle